Ex-Google, International tech speaker
Which VPN is better?
Review by our expert
New-Media and online expert, Venture Capitalist and investor
Latest positive user review
Latest negative user review
$3.49 / month
$1.99 / month
Money Back Guarantee (Days)
Number of devices per license
Best VPNs by category
With a great all-around package for security, privacy, and streaming, Surfshark manages to compete with the top names in the VPN industry in spite of being a new service. PIA, however, is a reliable budget VPN with some great features for the price. Unfortunately, it’s dragged down a little by geoblock bypassing problems and inconsistent speeds on some servers.
PIA is one of the world’s favorite VPNs for P2P file sharers, thanks to great extras like port forwarding and free SOCKS5 proxies. Surfshark isn’t on the same level yet when it comes to torrenting features. While the service allows P2P traffic, you’ll be rerouted to Netherlands servers. This limitation could result in an overloaded server and slower speeds.
Both VPNs chose a minimalist approach for their Windows clients, focusing on a user-friendly experience and essential features like quick connect and anti-leak settings. If you need a solid VPN for streaming, Surfshark is probably your better choice. PIA excels at basic privacy protection, however, thanks to 256-bit encryption and native OpenVPN support.
If you like having a kill switch in your Android VPN app, make note that only PIA offers one, along with a huge server network and one-tap protection. Surfshark for Android has its own appeal, with split tunneling and zero-knowledge DNS settings. But unlike PIA, it doesn’t come with built-in OpenVPN support.
You won’t find many differences between the Surfshark clients for Mac and Windows, apart from the use of the IKEv2 protocol instead of OpenVPN in the Mac app. You still get blazing speeds and lots of unblocking power, which is great news. Just like Surfshark, PIA is a great pick for securing your data and staying hidden online, but some geoblocks remain a difficult challenge for this VPN.
With a stable and easy-to-use client for iOS, Surfshark is exceptional in this category. What’s more, you can connect as many devices as you want with a single plan, which is perfect if you want VPN protection for the whole household. PIA brings a lot of value to the table, however, with a dependable iOS app and up to five connections at the same time.
At 1,400+ servers in the USA, PIA has a very strong presence in its home country. Unfortunately, most of those servers are blacklisted by the biggest American streaming services. Surfshark is modest but capable, with servers in nine US locations that give you reliable access to Netflix USA, Hulu, and many other US-only streams.