vpnMentor contains reviews that are written by our community reviewers, and are based on the reviewers' independent and professional examination of the products/services.
• Ownership
vpnMentor is owned by Kape Technologies PLC, which owns the following products: CyberGhost, ZenMate, Private Internet Access, and Intego, which may be reviewed on this website.
• Affiliate Commissions
While vpnMentor may receive commissions when a purchase is made using our links, this has no influence on the reviews content or on the reviewed products/services. We provide direct links to purchase products that are part of affiliate programs.
• Reviews Guidelines
The reviews published on vpnMentor are written by experts that examine the products according to our strict reviewing standards. Such standards ensure that each review is based on the independent, professional and honest examination of the reviewer, and takes into account the technical capabilities and qualities of the product together with its commercial value for users, which may also affect the product's ranking on the website.
Ran Greenberg
New-Media and online expert, Venture Capitalist and investor
HMA is one of the most well-established and reputable VPN providers in the industry, with over 900 servers in an amazing 190+ countries. Windscribe is a smaller provider by comparison, with around 300 servers in 55 countries, but also offers a complete and reliable service. If you ever have technical issues, you’ll find HMA’s 24/7 live chat very useful. Windscribe does not offer true live chat, but rather a 24/7 bot-operated chat system that has answers to the most common user questions and concerns. One of the best aspects of both providers’ services is that they provide dedicated apps for MacOS, Windows, iOS, and Android devices. Each provider has special features and services for unblocking US Netflix. Both also prioritize security and include strong encryption, a kill switch, and wi-fi protection across all platforms. Keep on reading to see which provider really has the best service when we consider every detail.
Features
9.4
Pricing
8.8
Ease of Use
9.4
Reliability & Support
8.0
Features
8.0
Pricing
8.6
Ease of Use
8.4
Reliability & Support
8.6
Rating
Features
9.4
8.0
0.0
Pricing
8.8
8.6
0.0
Ease of Use
9.4
8.4
0.0
Reliability & Support
8.0
8.6
0.0
Reviews
Review by our expert
Katie Kasunic
Technology Researcher
8.2
HMA is a popular VPN provider with a large network of 1,080+ servers in 210+ countries.
Some of this VPN’s biggest strengths are its user-friendly interface, impressive speeds, and ability to bypass geoblocks (even Netflix's!)
It's newest update, HMA Version 5, includes new design features and an auto-generated diagnostics mode. Arguably the most impressive update is its Lightning-mode feat...
Working perfectI like this excellent service a lot. It is working absolutely perfect. I have been using it for a couple of weeks, in my PC, in my mobile and also in an Asus router.
It is easy to order and setup, no matter which device.
Latest negative user review
Jorge
2.0
HMA won't keep you anonymous. LolThe most important aspect of a VPN is to keep you anonymous and secure, but that is something HMA will not do for you.
Cero logs policy, that's more like cero privacy protection. Check the LulzSec case where HMA ran to present the customers to the FBI.
Here the link:
theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/09/lulzsec-hacker-exposed-service-he-thought-would-hide-him/337545/
Windscribe VPN is a Canada-based provider that promises to help you browse the web privately.
In addition to its paid service, this VPN has a popular free version that attracts many users with its generous 10GB monthly data limit.
The Pro version gives you access to unlimited data and servers in 110 cities spread across 60 countries. Windscribe Pro also gives you the option of port forwardi...
Works well for the free versionThe free version was fast and offered the ability to unblock geo-restricted content, something I haven't seen any other free VPN (like protonvpn) do. Additionally, I have found that they offer a one-day free trial of a pro if you ask.
Latest negative user review
KAKA MTOMTAM
2.0
Servers randomly disconnect in IsraelServers randomly disconnect or start transferring in KB in Israel, the support is super bad and they don't know the windows services required to make the VPN work I had to figure out how to solve issues by myself.
HMA is a popular VPN provider with a large network of 1,080+ servers in 210+ countries.
Some of this VPN’s biggest strengths are its user-friendly interface, impressive speeds, and ability to bypass geoblocks (even Netflix's!)
It's newest update, HMA Version 5, includes new design features and an auto-generated diagnostics mode. Arguably the most impressive update is its Lightning-mode feat...
Windscribe VPN is a Canada-based provider that promises to help you browse the web privately.
In addition to its paid service, this VPN has a popular free version that attracts many users with its generous 10GB monthly data limit.
The Pro version gives you access to unlimited data and servers in 110 cities spread across 60 countries. Windscribe Pro also gives you the option of port forwardi...
Working perfectI like this excellent service a lot. It is working absolutely perfect. I have been using it for a couple of weeks, in my PC, in my mobile and also in an Asus router.
It is easy to order and setup, no matter which device.
PM
10.0
Works well for the free versionThe free version was fast and offered the ability to unblock geo-restricted content, something I haven't seen any other free VPN (like protonvpn) do. Additionally, I have found that they offer a one-day free trial of a pro if you ask.
Latest negative user review
Jorge
2.0
HMA won't keep you anonymous. LolThe most important aspect of a VPN is to keep you anonymous and secure, but that is something HMA will not do for you.
Cero logs policy, that's more like cero privacy protection. Check the LulzSec case where HMA ran to present the customers to the FBI.
Here the link:
theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/09/lulzsec-hacker-exposed-service-he-thought-would-hide-him/337545/
KAKA MTOMTAM
2.0
Servers randomly disconnect in IsraelServers randomly disconnect or start transferring in KB in Israel, the support is super bad and they don't know the windows services required to make the VPN work I had to figure out how to solve issues by myself.
HMA is a highly ranked VPN service with a large server network that spans almost every country, a 30-day money-back guarantee, and outstanding customer support. Windscribe is also a trustworthy VPN service provider with a free version, budget-friendly paid plans, and a decent array of features.
HMA is a highly ranked VPN service with a large server network that spans almost every country, a 30-day money-back guarantee, and outstanding customer support. Windscribe is also a trustworthy VPN service provider with a free version, budget-friendly paid plans, and a decent array of features.
HMA’s VPN allows you to download torrents without any restrictions. It has servers in multiple locations that are optimized for torrenting. Note that using other servers in the network for this purpose may not be secure. Windscribe also supports torrenting and P2P file sharing on many of its servers, with fast download speeds and unlimited bandwidth on all paid plans.
HMA’s VPN allows you to download torrents without any restrictions. It has servers in multiple locations that are optimized for torrenting. Note that using other servers in the network for this purpose may not be secure. Windscribe also supports torrenting and P2P file sharing on many of its servers, with fast download speeds and unlimited bandwidth on all paid plans.
With HMA’s dedicated Windows client, you get malware protection and access to the provider’s entire network of servers in 190 countries. Windscribe also provides a Windows app that features a very user-friendly design, ad blocking, and tracking protection.
With HMA’s dedicated Windows client, you get malware protection and access to the provider’s entire network of servers in 190 countries. Windscribe also provides a Windows app that features a very user-friendly design, ad blocking, and tracking protection.
By offering public wi-fi protection, an intuitive interface and an app that can be installed and set up within minutes, HMA provides a very reliable VPN service for Android users. Windscribe also provides an Android app with strong 256-bit encryption and a kill switch.
By offering public wi-fi protection, an intuitive interface and an app that can be installed and set up within minutes, HMA provides a very reliable VPN service for Android users. Windscribe also provides an Android app with strong 256-bit encryption and a kill switch.
With HMA’s MacOS app, you’ll have IPv6 leak protection, strong encryption, and access to ultra-fast servers. Windscribe also offers a very robust VPN service for MacOS, with a responsive user interface and features like a built-in firewall and ad blocking.
With HMA’s MacOS app, you’ll have IPv6 leak protection, strong encryption, and access to ultra-fast servers. Windscribe also offers a very robust VPN service for MacOS, with a responsive user interface and features like a built-in firewall and ad blocking.
One of the best features of the HMA iOS app is that it offers 24/7 customer support via live chat from within the app. The app also offers access to all 900+ servers in the provider’s network. However, if your family owns numerous iOS gadgets, you’ll love that Windscribe not only provides a user-friendly dedicated app but also allows unlimited simultaneous connections.
One of the best features of the HMA iOS app is that it offers 24/7 customer support via live chat from within the app. The app also offers access to all 900+ servers in the provider’s network. However, if your family owns numerous iOS gadgets, you’ll love that Windscribe not only provides a user-friendly dedicated app but also allows unlimited simultaneous connections.
HMA offers more than a hundred US servers for bypassing geoblocks from anywhere, and although it lacks the speed and consistency of the best VPN services like ExpressVPN and NordVPN, it capably unblocks Netflix. Windscribe also provides a reliable VPN service for the USA, with dedicated Windflix servers that unblock Netflix and many other US-based websites and services.
HMA offers more than a hundred US servers for bypassing geoblocks from anywhere, and although it lacks the speed and consistency of the best VPN services like ExpressVPN and NordVPN, it capably unblocks Netflix. Windscribe also provides a reliable VPN service for the USA, with dedicated Windflix servers that unblock Netflix and many other US-based websites and services.
The Bottom Line
Ran Greenberg
New-Media and online expert, Venture Capitalist and investor
HMA wins this comparison by offering a more complete and reliable service overall. HMA’s advanced leak protection, true 24/7 live chat support, and 30-day money-back guarantee are key points in its favor. Windscribe offers only a 3-day refund policy, and human support is available exclusively via email. The most obvious advantage of HMA over Windscribe, however, is its global network presence, with servers distributed across across 190 countries.
Interestingly, if you compare HMA VPN with ExpressVPN, which is our top ranked vpn, you'll see that HMA VPN can learn a lot from ExpressVPN. Compare HMA VPN with ExpressVPN
Honesty and Transparency are two core values of vpnMentor. VPN Companies can't pay to change or delete reviews. When readers choose to buy a vpn service, we sometimes earn affiliate commissions that support our work. Here is an explanation of exactly what we do, and how to support our work.
