Hotspot Shield vs
Private Internet Access vs
TunnelBear VPN

After comparing these VPNs, we have a winner!


Which VPN is better?

Catherine Ablett
Cybersecurity Researcher

On the surface these three providers, Hotspot Shield, PIA (Private Internet Access), and TunnelBear all offer similar services, all of which allow users to securely access the web while safeguarding their privacy. However, there are some considerable differences that need to be highlighted. All offer reasonable speeds and good encryption, but only PIA and TunnelBear offer a choice of connection methods, since users of Hotspot Shield can only connect via OpenVPN. All three providers have server locations across the globe with Hotspot Shield leading the way with over 90 server locations, however, PIA leaps ahead with in the region of 3000 servers, compared to Hotspot Shield’s 200. No server numbers are given by TunnelBear. All three offer mobile solutions and are suitable for public Wi-Fi hotspot usage. They also can be used to access geo-restricted content, although access is to Netflix is not guaranteed through TunnelBear. TunnelBear does not support the use of BitTorrent at all, while both Hotspot Shield and PIA can be used for Torrents; PIA does not support torrenting on its US servers.






 Best VPNs by category


 The Bottom Line

Catherine Ablett
Cybersecurity Researcher

PIA is a clear winner when compared to these two other providers. It offers the stronger encryption, security and privacy, and better customer service. It is the only one of the three that guarantees not to keep any logs of any type, and which provides users with a kill switch. It offers better value for money in relation to the service levels it provides, with subscriptions prices being related to length of subscription rather than bandwidth or speed allowances. It also has the best customer service options and, of course, the greater choice of servers that can be accessed.

Interestingly, if you compare Private Internet Access with NordVPN, which is our top ranked vpn, you'll see that Private Internet Access can learn a lot from NordVPN. Compare Private Internet Access with NordVPN